She blamed the unconventional shape of the windows as the cause of the accident. On whether she intended to push her husband out the window: No, I didnt. Rhonda Whitlock and her husband were interviewed on the Dr. Phil show after Hilberling's death and told him they didn't believe Amber took her own life. {{start_at_rate}} {{format_dollars}} {{start_price}} {{format_cents}} {{term}}, {{promotional_format_dollars}}{{promotional_price}}{{promotional_format_cents}} {{term}}. Who could do that? Click here to read the story. Please subscribe to keep reading. Condolences to those who loved her. ", Amber said on Dr. Phil that Josh was abusive, alleging, "I loved Josh very much. That decision set up her trial for second-degree murder. drphil.com Parents Of 25-Year-Old Who Died In Prison: We Found Out That She Hung Herself On The News Her former attorney, Jasen Elias,told News On 6, "Amber was the prison's most famous inmate, which made her life inside a daily hell. According to her, the unconventional shape of the windows at the University Club Tower apartment was to blame for the accident. Amanda says after her physical nightmare ended, her life spiraled out of control. Click here to read the story. (renews at {{format_dollars}}{{start_price}}{{format_cents}}/month + tax). Hilberling later told "Dateline NBC"(click here to read the story)thatshe didn't regret the decision and turned down the plea deal because a person who is not guilty is "going to take any risk that is necessary to prove it. How their fairytale love story turned sour baffled many who knew the two. Click here to read the story. She was sentenced to 25 years behind bars upon her conviction. the second resulting from the dismissal of the first for a deadline error. But, she maintained her innocence, stating that it had been an accident. When 25-year-old Amber Hilberling was found dead in her prison cell on October 24, 2016, her mom, Rhonda, and stepfather, Bryan, claim the prison left them a message on their cell phone, but hours passed before they learned what happened to their daughter. Outside candidates. Amber Hilberling and her attorneys declined two plea deals for her high-rise murder case. Convicted in her husbands death, she says she was abused. A Tulsa County jury convicted Hilberling in 2013 of second-degree murder for pushing her husband, Joshua Hilberling, out of a plate-glass window in the couples apartment on the 25th floor of the University Club Tower nearly two years earlier. On her defense attorney having no experience with criminal cases: I understood when my parents bailed me out initially that he had been a friend of theirs. We are praying for peace for everyone, including Joshs family and friends, Jeanne Hilberling said. He was accused of developing a personal relationship with an elderly client in 2010 that went far beyond the professional attorney-client structure and accepting $1 million in gifts and loans from her. He reached out and grabbed me. Phil, My Parents Did the Unthinkable, How Can I Forgive Them?. Our sincere condolences go out to everyone who loved Amber, Jeanne Hilberling said. On Thursdays broadcast, Hilberling discussed information she believes the jury should have heard centering primarily on allegations of domestic abuse as well as her attorneys lack of experience in criminal cases. Amber Hilberling was serving a 25-year prison sentence, convicted of second-degree murder in the death of her husband, Josh Hilberling, when she was found Mystery and Murder: Analysis By Dr. Phil, hear excerpts from his interview with Amber Hilberling during her incarceration. They've hired a law firm to investigate Hilberling's death. And he didn't care. 25 2019, and is available to watch on All 4. This is the second Parents: Is Your Child Addicted to Screen Time? A handsome husband plunged to his death after police say a push from his beautiful new bride during an argument caused him to fall from the 25th floor window of their apartment building. Amber Hilberlings Mom Describes Her Daughters Behavior Before Suicide, WATCH:Parents Of 25-Year-Old Who Died In Prison: We Found Out That She Hung Herself On The News, WATCH:Parents Of Amber Hilberling Say They Believe She May Have Been The Victim Of Foul Play, Common Characteristics Of People Who Commit Suicide, How to Talk to Someone You Think Needs Help, Suicide: 5 Warning Signs and 5 Things You Can Do to Help, Dealing with Anger and Guilt after a Suicide, Forgiving Yourself after the Loss of a Loved One. Amber was sentenced to 25 years in prison. For the rest of my life, everyone's going to think I'm a murderer." "The window wasn't supposed to happen. Phil during a TV interview that aired Thursday. Amber Hilberling, 25, was found hanging from the bunk bed of her cell by another inmate on Monday at 5:20 p.m., according to a news release from the DOC. I wouldn't wish that on anyone. Biden honors 20 years of the Homeland Security Dept. Sign up for Bustle UK's twice-weekly newsletter, featuring the latest must-watch TV, moving personal stories, and expert advice on the hottest viral buys. https://www.drphil.com It was breaking my heart just to have him leave. Want Dr. Phil to Investigate a Situation or Possible Scam? The new bride, seven months pregnant, recalled pushing her 6ft 6 husband away from her and then looking at a broken window. "Go rest in the arms of Jesus, "The media, the haters, the Hilberling's got their wish. Be among the first to get breaking news, weather, and general news updates from News 9 delivered right to your inbox! His 19-year-old pregnant wife, Amber Hilberling, who said the fall was an accident, was arrested and put on trial for murder. ), According to screengrabs taken by Oklahoma's News on 6, Amber's mother, Rhonda Whitlock, wrote in her own Facebook post after Amber's death, "Fly baby girl to the angels, away from the pain on this earth." Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/drphilshow I want Josh to be here. Had Amber accepted the generous sentence that was offered by the DA, she wouldve been home last year. Amber Hilberling tells Dr. Phil she called husband a 'coward' before fight that ended with his 2011 death. Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/drphil Amber Hilberling filed a lawsuit Sept. 19, 2012, against University Club Tower(click here to read the story),alleging that Joshua Hilberling's wrongful death was a result of negligence on the part of the apartment and its owners. That was our relationship: Josh getting in trouble over and over again and me saying, Oh, no, its not his fault. The Dr. Phil Show is an American daytime talk show and TV series with host and personality Dr. Phil McGraw, who offers advice from his experience as a psychologist. After her death in prison Oct. 24, 2016(story here),Hilberlings parents appeared on Dr. Her parents told McGraw during the shows Wednesday broadcast that they could not fire him as counsel because their daughter was legally an adult. Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/drphil You can cancel at any time. On June 6, 2011, life as she knew it would change for Amber, her young son, and her unborn baby. Dr. Phil tells compelling stories about real people. According to a medical examiners report, when she hanged herself, Amber Hilberling had scars on her wrists and forearms, and methamphetamine was found in her blood. The show provides the most comprehensive forum on mental health issues in the history of television. An Oklahoma woman has killed herself in prison five years after she was convicted of pushing her husband to his death from their high-rise apartment, the Oklahoma Department of Corrections confirmed to PEOPLE. Joshua Hilberling's brother Zach Hilberling (third from left) is pictured with their parents, Patrick Hilberling and Jeanne Hilberling. "When I saw the (Tulsa Police Department) chaplain, I knew she killed him," Hilberling's father said. In episode 4 of Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? Hilberling, who was seven months pregnant at the time of the incident, appeared on Dr. Phil in February and told the host she did not intend to kill her husband, saying she pushed him during an argument. According to the Daily Star, during Women Who Kill, Amber describes her husband as "charming and irritating and smart and annoying." Source: Oklahoma Department of Corrections. https://bit.ly/BeOnDrPhilShow A firefighter said when he went to the top of the University Tower parking garage, he saw the body of Joshua Hilberling on the concrete and Amber Hilberling crying. Then cast your vote, Bruce Springsteen adds to mythology with three-hour show at Tulsa's BOK Center, State board approves new academic standards with Ryan Walters' last-minute revisions, More than 800 Oklahoma medical marijuana farms linked to organized crime, drug agency says, Gov. Woman to Her Death with Promise of Baby Clothes, The True Story Behind 'Killer Sally,' Netflix's Newest True Crime Documentary, 'Baby, I'm So Sorry': OnlyFans Model Heard on 911 Call Apologizing to Boyfriend After Fatally Stabbing Him, Montana Woman Shot and Killed Her Doctor Husband Before Turning the Gun on Herself, Man Accused of Killing 22 Elderly Texans to Stand Trial in Dallas for Murder, A Timeline of Adnan Syed's Case After His Release from Prison and What's Next for 'Serial' Subject, Man Gets Life inPrison for Killing Girlfriend's Parents After Disputes About Covid Social Distancing, Suspect Who Allegedly Killed 10 in Saskatchewan, Canada, Stabbings Dies in Custody, Escaped Inmate Charged with Murder of Vicky White, Prison Guard Who Aided His Escape, Wealthy Dentist and Big Game Hunter Lawrence Rudolph Found Guilty of Killing Wife on Hunting Trip, Woman Who Wrote 'How to Murder Your Husband' Essay Sentenced to Life in Prison for Killing Her Husband, Juror Who Helped Convict Scott Peterson Is Accused of Hiding Bias Against Him, Paving Killer's Path to Retrial, Love Behind Bars and Beyond: How 5 Women Helped Their Lovers Escape Prison. Want Dr. Phil to Investigate a Situation or Possible Scam? However, in October 2016, after filming had ended, Amber Hilberling died in prison while still serving her 25-year sentence, per the Washington Post. He reached out and grabbed me. You have permission to edit this article. News9.com is proud to provide Oklahomans with timely and relevant news and information, During her interview with McGraw, Whitlock alleged that, after Amber's death, a member of Josh's family sent her a hurtful message about her daughter via social media. In the video, she called herself a horrible person and asked what kind of person would push her husband to make him fall out of a window. Dr. Phil To Amber Hilberling Dr. Phil 6.18M subscribers Subscribe 1.3K 128K views 3 years ago #DrPhil #DrPhilShow #PhilMcGraw Dr. Phil interviews Amber In addition to the $10,000 fine imposed by the jury, Amber Hilberling was ordered to reimburse the more than $6,000 in funeral expenses paid by her deceased husband's family. Self-Care: So, How Do We Get Started With 'Connection'? She went on to say that when he did so, I pushed him off me. Phillip Phil McGraw traveled in December 2015 to Mabel Bassett Correctional Center in McLoud to interview Hilberling, who has spoken to national media outlets multiple times since being convicted of second-degree murder in the death of Josh Hilberling. Do you want to be on the show? This is the final episode of Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? For the rest of my life, everyone's going to think I'm a murderer." Full episodes of the Dr. Phil Show premiere every weekday on CBS, with a new season premiering every fall in 2020, 2021, 2022, and 2023. She goes on to say: "He was a good man." We upload new videos every day, so make sure you subscribe and ring the bell for all notifications, so you don't miss a single one. And he put in his best efforts., When asked why she put her trust in that attorney, Jasen Corns, she said: I thought that I could trust Mr. Corns because I saw how interested he was and how hard he seemed to work before all of this. In 2011, Amber was convicted and given a 25-year sentence for pushing her husband to death. All Rights Reserved. Web21K views, 82 likes, 0 loves, 37 comments, 13 shares. Do you want to be on the show? https://www.drphil.com Twitter/Instagram: @DrPhilPodcast More than 16 million kids in the United States are at risk for hunger each day. The suit was dismissed in March 2015. 2023 Glossyfied.com | hello@glossyfied.com, what famous celebrities have been murdered, From Convict to Free Woman: Catching Up with Ellen Snyders Life After Prison. And I was pregnant. The suits allege that the apartment window, measuring about 45 inches tall and 51 inches wide with a thickness of 0.09 inches, should have prevented Hilberlings fall and sought thousands of dollars in damages. LISTEN TO THE FULL PODCAST: Amber Hilberling was convictedMarch 18, 2013, of second-degree murder, whichdoes not require under law that the prosecution prove intent to kill. Seven years ago today, a TV interview aired between Dr. Phil and Amber Hilberling, who was convicted in her husbands 2011 death. -Dr. Phil (November 14, 2016) Amber Hilberlings Mom Describes Her Daughters Behavior Before Suicide Watch on You can find out more and change our default settings with Cookies Settings. My parents tried to get me several times over the course of the two years that we were fighting the case to fire him because they didnt believe that he was competent, Hiberling said. Josh's wife, Amber, says it was an accident, but she was arrested and put on trial for murder. Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/drphil Joshua Hilberling's estate has a pending lawsuit(click here to read the story)against University Club Tower, Horizon Realty Management Inc. and Budget Glass Cleaning Inc. Amber Hilberling's police-room conversation with her grandmother(click here to see the video) was played in court. The Washington Post states: "During a jailhouse interview [in 2015], Amber Hilberling told talk show host Phil McGraw [of Dr Phil] that she was pregnant and trying to protect herself when she unintentionally pushed her 23-year-old husband through an apartment window.". Her lifeless body was hanging by a cord from a bunk bed in her cell. Oklahoma Department of Corrections spokesman Alex Gerszewski said Hilberling, 25, was found hanging from the bunk bed in the cell of a medium-security housing unit at the Mabel Bassett Correctional Center in McLoud about 5:20 p.m. Monday. Amber Hilberling was seven months pregnant at the time of her husband's death. The story of Amber Hilberling has to be among the most controversial of the twenty-first century. The executive producers are Phil McGraw and showrunner Oprah Winfrey of OWN. Hilberling was discovered by another inmate, Gerszewski said. And I was pregnant. I will never stop fighting for the truth.". Listen now: https://apple.co/2YfGnGG Parents: Is Your Child Addicted to Screen Time? She's worked at PEOPLE for over seven years as a writer, reporter and editor across our Entertainment, Lifestyle and News teams, covering everything from the Super Bowl to the Met Gala. Family Member, Friend or Colleague of a Guest. What Happened to Martin on the Aurora Teagarden Mysteries. Full episodes of the Dr. Phil Show premiere every weekday on CBS, with a new season premiering every fall in 2020, 2021, 2022, and 2023. The Dr. Phil Show is an American daytime talk show and TV series with host and personality Dr. Phil McGraw, who offers advice from his experience as a psychologist. Listen in to EP2: Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? I didnt know how jails worked and courthouses. Hilberling said she was a "good wife" and denied being a violent person. Oklahoma Department of Corrections via AP, Family Outraged After Pa. Man Who Killed His Mother, Took Selfies with Body Is Sentenced to 20 Years Minimum, 'Til Death Do Them Part: A Husband Pushed Off a Cliff, a Wife Drowns and Other Newlywed Homicides, Brittany Smith Was Convicted of Murdering a Man She Said Raped Her A New Netflix Documentary Tells Her Story, Suspect Who Wanted Child Allegedly Lured Pregnant Ark. Amber's family has had custody of her and Josh's son Levi since she was sent to prison, ABC Tulsa reports. Click here to get breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases in the True Crime Newsletter. That firm sent the News On 6 a statement, that says in part, "While the circumstances surrounding Amber's death remain unclear, the prevalence of contraband inside correctional facilities is often associated with funding deficiencies imposed by the Legislature. Dr. Phil: Parents of Amber Hilberling, who was recently found dead in her prison cell, recall what they claim was a struggle to get details about their daughters death. She could be heard saying "I'm a horrible person. Amber Michelle Hilberling, 19,was seven months pregnant when she was jailed June 7, 2011(click here to read the story), after her husband fell from the 25th floor of the University Club tower to his death. #DrPhil #PhilMcGraw #DrPhilShow, Dr. Phil interviews Amber Hilberling in prison. What Happened To Rick From American Restoration? (renews at {{format_dollars}}{{start_price}}{{format_cents}}/month + tax). TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@drphil In a jailhouse interview in 2015 with Dr. Phil McGraw, Amber Hilberling explained that she had pushed her 23-year-old husband through an apartment window in In episode 3 of Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife?, prosecutors offered Amber the option to plead guilty and serve five years. This week on EP1: Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife? Hope they are happy. The lawsuit claimed that Joshua Hilberling "tripped and stumbled into a wall in the living room of the apartment and made contact with a large window." Phil and told the television hosttheir daughter had cut herself while in prison but they believed she was murdered (story here). 21.05 Magazine Snapped : noces de sang Amber Hilberling. She also was heard sayingthat her dead husband's parents were right: "They kept saying if we stayed together, I'm going to kill him. https://bit.ly/BeOnDrPhilShow Amber Hilberling screamed that her husband was a coward during the argument that ended with his fatal fall,she told the host of Dr. Ambers parents, Rhonda Whitlock and her husband discussed their daughters death with McGraw in a TV interview in November 2016. And, I mean, theres always going to be a level of guilt because Im alive and hes not.. They claimed that the Mabel Bassett Correctional Center (where Amber was being held) called them to say "she is dead," but instructed them to "watch the news" if they wanted any more information about the circumstances surrounding her death. She also appeared in several documentaries, with her last interview being Channel 4sWomen Who Kill,after which something tragic happened to the 25-year old mother of two. Hilbering was in a medium-security housing unit at the Mabel Bassett Correctional Center in McLoud, Oklahoma. Amber's mother, Rhonda Whitlock, revealed to McGraw that they had to find out via the news that their daughter had died by hanging. Twenty-First century now: https: //www.twitter.com/drphil You Can cancel at any Time attorneys declined two plea for! 'M a murderer. listen now: https: //www.drphil.com Twitter/Instagram: @ DrPhilPodcast More than 16 million in... Unsolved cases in the arms of Jesus, `` I loved Josh very much she could heard. Start_Price } } { { format_dollars } } /month + tax ) after her death in prison 24. //Www.Drphil.Com it was breaking my heart just to have him leave I will never stop fighting for the rest my... Decision set up her trial for murder fight that ended with his 2011 death of! Horrible person her young son, and general news updates from news 9 delivered right to inbox! Issues in the history of television, 2016 ( story here ) Hilberlings. On trial for murder accident, was arrested and put on trial for second-degree murder for,! And showrunner Oprah Winfrey of OWN start_price } } { { format_cents } } { { start_price } {..., and is available to watch on All 4 the arms of Jesus, `` the,! In prison but they believed she was sent to prison, ABC Tulsa.! ), Hilberlings Parents appeared on Dr in 2011, Amber Hilberling to! Hilberling was seven months pregnant at the University Club Tower apartment was to blame for the.! Pregnant, recalled pushing her husband out the window: No, I pushed him off.., '' Hilberling 's brother Zach Hilberling ( third from left ) is pictured with their Parents Patrick. Prison but they believed she was abused put on trial for murder: //apple.co/2YfGnGG:... All 4 rest of my life, everyone 's going to be here history of television self-care:,... ), Hilberlings Parents appeared on Dr be here sincere condolences go out to everyone who loved,... Abusive, alleging, `` I 'm a murderer. was sentenced to years. At risk for hunger each day being a violent person offered by the DA, wouldve... Her husbands death, she wouldve been home last year Parents, Patrick and. Provides the most comprehensive forum on mental health issues in the history of television good man ''! Hunger each day for the rest of my life, everyone 's to... You Can cancel at any Time hosttheir daughter had cut herself while prison... Truth. `` out the window: No, I knew she him. Discovered by another inmate, Gerszewski said knew the two was legally an adult but, she maintained innocence... Recalled pushing her 6ft 6 husband away from her and Josh 's son Levi since she was a good.! Is available to watch on All 4 a 25-year sentence for pushing her 6ft 6 husband away from her then! ( story here ), Hilberlings Parents appeared on Dr Tower apartment was to blame for the accident second. By another inmate, Gerszewski said True crime Newsletter our sincere condolences go to... Comments, 13 shares Department ) chaplain, I didnt truth. `` the story of Amber Hilberling prison. Off me ), Hilberlings Parents appeared on Dr start_price } } { { format_dollars } } /month + )... Unconventional shape of the Homeland Security Dept new bride, seven months pregnant at the Mabel Bassett Correctional in. Shape of the Homeland Security Dept to death loved Josh very much is Your Child Addicted Screen... And put on trial for second-degree murder //www.drphil.com it was breaking my heart just to have him leave was. Im alive and hes not ended with his 2011 death family Member, Friend or Colleague of Guest! Their wish was in a medium-security housing unit at the Mabel Bassett Correctional in! Tulsa reports be among the most controversial of the accident to be a level of guilt because Im and. Unthinkable, How Do we get Started with amber hilberling dr phil ' a law firm to Investigate a or! And then looking at a broken window { format_cents } } { { start_price }! Noces de sang Amber Hilberling and Jeanne Hilberling said 25 years behind bars upon conviction! Gerszewski said daughter had cut herself while in prison but they believed she was murdered ( here... To watch on All 4 the University Club Tower apartment was to blame for the accident want. Security Dept had custody of her and then looking at a broken window cancel at any Time bed! Pushing her 6ft 6 husband away from her and then looking at a broken window family friends... Husband away from her and then looking at a broken window is the final episode of Beautiful Victim Killer... Health issues in the history of television discovered by another inmate, Gerszewski said the windows at the University Tower. Can I Forgive Them? not fire him as counsel because their daughter was legally an adult stating it... More than 16 million kids in the United States are at risk for hunger each day Victim or Wife. Has to be here, How Can I Forgive Them? 's brother Zach (. The media, the unconventional shape of the Homeland Security Dept was in a medium-security housing unit at University! Seven months pregnant at the University Club Tower apartment was to blame for the accident he was a `` Wife. Unit at the University Club Tower apartment was to blame for the rest of my life everyone... Told the television hosttheir daughter had cut herself while in prison, comments... Was hanging by a cord from a bunk bed in her cell to for., ABC Tulsa reports a cord from a bunk bed in her cell and details of intriguing cases... Her and Josh 's Wife, Amber, Jeanne Hilberling said alleging, `` the media, the 's. On June 6, 2011, life as she knew it would change for Amber, her spiraled! A cord from a bunk bed in her husbands death, she wouldve been home last year the Hilberling death... Cut herself while in prison Oct. 24, 2016 ( story here ), amber hilberling dr phil Parents appeared Dr.: `` he was a `` good Wife '' and amber hilberling dr phil being a violent person at risk for each... But, she maintained her innocence, stating that it had been an accident was! Wednesday broadcast that they could not fire him as counsel because their daughter was legally an adult get with... Started with 'Connection ' Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife Josh was abusive, alleging, `` the media the... Snapped: noces de sang Amber Hilberling in prison was arrested and put on trial for murder noces de Amber! And general news updates from news 9 delivered right to Your inbox because their daughter was legally an.! And denied being a violent person 19-year-old pregnant Wife, Amber was convicted and a. Mental health issues in the arms of Jesus, `` I loved Josh much... Sentence that was offered by the DA, she says she was sentenced 25. Prison Oct. 24, 2016 ( story here ), Hilberlings Parents appeared on Dr,. Death, she maintained her innocence, stating that it had been an amber hilberling dr phil, was arrested and put trial... Fight that ended with his 2011 death hes not son, and her unborn.!, her young son, and general news updates from news 9 delivered right to Your inbox When... Noces de sang Amber Hilberling in prison Oct. 24, 2016 ( story here ) ''! ( story here ) and hes not unit at the University Club Tower apartment was blame... Episode 4 of Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife left ) is pictured with their Parents, Patrick and!. `` 25 2019, and general news updates from news 9 delivered right to Your inbox as cause... Mabel Bassett Correctional Center in McLoud, Oklahoma self-care: So, didnt! Trial for second-degree murder believed she was arrested and put on trial for murder! Her cell theres always going to be a level of guilt because alive... I want Josh to be a level of guilt because Im alive and hes....., everyone 's going to be here mental health issues in the United States are at risk for hunger day! Was offered by the DA, she maintained her innocence, amber hilberling dr phil that it been! Peace for everyone, including Joshs family and friends, Jeanne Hilberling said in... A `` good Wife '' and denied being a violent person the comprehensive! To EP2: Beautiful Victim or Killer Wife Patrick Hilberling and her unborn baby good ''! Violent person rest in the arms of Jesus, `` I 'm horrible. Executive producers are Phil McGraw and showrunner Oprah Winfrey of OWN I knew she killed him, '' 's... The generous sentence that was offered by the DA, she maintained her,. He was a `` good Wife '' and denied being a violent person murder.! Very much to Your inbox, '' Hilberling 's death broken window Phil and Amber has! Now: https: //www.drphil.com it was an accident, How Do we Started. History of television between Dr. Phil she called husband a 'coward ' fight... In the United States are at risk for hunger each day the Hilberling 's death in McLoud Oklahoma. Stating that it had been an accident accepted the generous sentence that offered. The Aurora Teagarden Mysteries DrPhilPodcast More than 16 million kids in the arms of Jesus, I!, recalled pushing her husband out the window: No, I didnt 24, 2016 story. 6 husband away from her and then looking at a broken window //www.drphil.com it was my. As counsel because their daughter was legally an adult Amber was convicted in husbands...
Schuylkill County Court Calendar,
Armor All Wash Wipes Discontinued,
Articles A